Former U.K. Chief Rabbi Jonathan Sacks once said that living a Jewish life requires “taking a stand against the corrosive power of hate.” Jews know all too well what it feels like to be demonized and alienated by right-wing populists. Yet, there are some Jewish Emory students who have excused themselves of the responsibility advocated by Rabbi Sacks through the flimsy justification that Jews have benefited under President Donald Trump’s administration.
I have little doubt that most within my community will back the Democratic nominee this November. Nevertheless, this article isn’t directed at the many Jews who will do the right thing and vote for Joe Biden, but rather the minority that will be judged by history as enablers of our current president. It is they who have compromised profoundly Jewish principles for a man who is falsely viewed as our advocate.
Trump’s friends within the Jewish community at Emory cite his unswerving embrace of Israel and his Jewish grandchildren as the rationale for supporting him. However, this argument disregards the suffering that Jews have endured as a consequence of Trump’s rhetoric, that which has legitimized the scapegoating of minorities and opened the door for a hatred that has never bode well for the Jewish people. As Emory Religion Professor Deborah Lipstadt argued, this form of overt prejudice targeting whole groups — though dormant for a long time — has resurfaced in a climate in which the president “talks about ‘hordes’ and ‘swarms’” of immigrants. Unlike Joe Biden who has condemned the “anti-Semitic bile” on display at Charlottesville, Virginia, and distanced himself from the anti-Semitism promulgated by figures within his own party, Trump has consistently flirted with a political ideology that targets Jews, Muslims and anyone who does not fit a narrow vision of white-only America.
To be clear, Trump is not an anti-Semite. However, one does not have to be hateful of Jewish people to lend credence to those who do. It is no coincidence that Trump’s tenure has witnessed an upsurge in anti-Semitic attacks, including the worst one in U.S. history at the Tree of Life Synagogue in Pittsburgh. The perpetrator acted on a twisted belief that Jews were part of a nefarious plot to assist in the “invasion” of the U.S. by a caravan of Latin American migrants. This vicious lie came straight from the mouth of the man who occupies the Oval Office. Yes, this president contributed to the worst anti-Semitic attack in American memory. Yet certain Jewish proponents of the right continue to label him a champion of our people.
Granted, Trump has scored relatively high in his record on Israel. I supported him in brokering the most recent peace deal between Israel and the United Arab Emirates, and praised him for moving the U.S. embassy from Tel Aviv, Israel, to Jerusalem. Even still, to argue that Biden is so “anti-Israel” that Jews should not vote for him is absurd. In fact, the President Emeritus of the Union for Reform Judaism Eric Yoffie has gone so far as to describe the Biden-Harris ticket as the “dream team for the Jewish state.” Yoffie is not wrong. In spite of Trump’s best attempts to paint Biden as a surrogate for Ilhan Omar and Rashida Tlaib, Biden has resisted calls to put conditions on U.S. aid provided to Israel, labelled himself as a staunch Zionist who “loves Israel” and rightfully lambasted the Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions movement as “wrong” and “anti-Semitic.”
A Biden presidency would certainly be better for Israel than a Trump second term. As an ardent supporter of the Middle-East’s only democracy (albeit sometimes critical of certain policies), I not only favor Biden on unrelated issues — such as the Supreme Court, women’s rights and healthcare — but I also prefer him when it comes to our nation-state. I submit that it is better for Israel to have a liberal supporter in the White House than a divisive stalwart. Biden is the president who will push the Israelis to make the sacrifices that are conducive to peace (and protective of Palestinian rights). Additionally, his views will have a positive impact in the circles where support for Israel has waned in recent years. These are circles where extremists, largely aided by the current president’s actions pertaining to the Middle-East, have begun to succeed in their crusade to present Israel as synonymous with the right and anathema to the left.
While the reelection of Trump would only exacerbate the worsening partisan divide, the election of a liberal president, who strongly backs Israel, will go a long way in shoring up support amongst wavering Democrats — especially on college campuses such as ours. This hope is reaffirmed by veteran Middle-East negotiator Aaron David Miller, who considers the recent rift in bipartisan support as “not yet fatal,” but “potentially catastrophic should the Trump-Netanyahu experience continue.”
For these reasons, the justifications used by most Jewish Trump supporters to overlook this president’s many shortcomings are dubious. Indeed, the arguments made by Lipstadt and Miller affirm that Jews should not vote for Trump, especially if they’re basing their support on his zero-sum backing of Israel or on a fallacious belief that he has made America a safer place for Jews. It is a great shame that some within my community have mistakenly come to view Trump, and his Republican apparatchiks, as our only true friends in Washington. Blinded by this flawed perception, too many have neglected this president’s egregious incompetence, unprecedented corruption and immoral scapegoating of minority groups.
Though I have faith that the majority of American Jews will turn out for Biden as they did for Barack Obama, to see members of my own strata ignore Trump’s advancement of his white nationalist agenda just 70 years after the Shoah is deeply upsetting. Political activist and Holocaust survivor Elie Wiesel swore to “never be silent and always take a side in the face of suffering and humiliation.” American Jews must make a choice this upcoming November — and it’s clear what side we must take.
Joe Beare (23C) is from London, England.
Joe Beare (23C) is from London, majoring in political science and history. Beare is a player on the Emory men’s soccer team and enjoys reading, discussing politics and watching soccer with his friends. He intends to go to law school and run for elected office in the U.S.
Wow this is garbage reporting. Do you all not even pretend to fact check things anymore?
Agree, this is garbage.
Brilliant well said Joe!
This is beautiful reporting in every way. For anyone who thinks otherwise, you would do well to provide your own facts to refute these well written points.
Jews Who died in holocaust must be crying from their graves these people millions where burned in ovens by men like Donald trump not to mention He’s He’s GERMAN! have jews forgotten are do they not care anymore.(Dont forget when wicked germans ran out of gas for the ovens they threw children in the ovens alive
Garbage content, Trump is the best friend for Jews and for a israel. TRUMP 2020
The only friend Trump has is himself.
It’s clear a child is writing this for school credit. First, it ignores Biden’s participation in Obama’s blatantly anti-Israel actions, including the embracing of Iran and the palestinian narrative on Judea/Samaria, not to mention the driving of UNSC Resolution 2334. Secondly, while taking aim at Trump’s supposed (and totally mischaracterized) support for right wing groups, none of which can actually be substantiated by actual words or deeds, this child completely ignores (perhaps being a Brit and ignorant of US politics is at fault) the antisemitism of the democratic party. With members like Ilhan Omar & Rashida Tlaib who have no shame in expressing Jew hatred, to their enablers like AOC, Ayanna Pressley, etc., to self-hating Jew Bernie Sanders to whom it is more important to prove h0w left he is than being Jewish (he’s in good company with such figures as Marx, Trotsky, Torquemada, Pablo Christiani, etc.), the congressional black caucus members and the Clintons who sat next to, vetted and embraced arch race baiter and Jew hater Louis Farrakhan. It is a great shame that leftist Jews, especially young and naive ones act against their own interest. As for non-Americans, your opinions about how we conduct our elections should be kept to yourselves, lest you open your actions, such as supporting outright Jew haters like Jeremy Corbyn, to equal derision and criticism.
Imagine writing an essay in response to an article written by someone who you believe is a “naive child”. What a sad life Wayne.
P.s. Joe is a family member of mine. He is a dual citizen, a loyal supporter of Israel and he voted for Boris Johnson last December. Sorry to break it to you but not not every Jewish person who is centre-left, or rather not every Jewish person who has a brain and thus opposes Trump, is a “self-hating Jew”.
Even if this article had been written in English it would not have fooled anyone with a brain. It was written by a moron with no education.
The fact that you have to target people as opposed to ideas shows that you have nothing to rebuke this smart kid’s ideas.
OK, I cannot believe as a Jew, you cannot recognize the good, yes good, Trump has done for Israel with 3 history deals: UAE, Baharin, and now Sudan. So, you would cut off you nose to spite your face! For shame. Your hate and bigotry is what is the problem and for you to think that Jews do not have a brain is a sin in itself.
You clearly didn’t read the article. The kid clearly acknowledged the good Trump has done for Israel. “Granted, Trump has scored relatively high in his record on Israel. I supported him in brokering the most recent peace deal between Israel and the United Arab Emirates, and praised him for moving the U.S. embassy from Tel Aviv, Israel, to Jerusalem.”
Maybe you should read what the article says before you comment on it.
Let’s break this down:
1. “Jews know all too well what it feels like to be demonized and alienated by right-wing populists.”
Jews in England just turned out to defeat Jeremy Corbyn, a Left Wing Populist.
And Jews in the USA gave a meager 10% of their votes
to Socialist Populist Bernie Sanders in the 2020 Democratic Primaries.
And Bernie may have once been a Jew.
2. ” the president “talks about ‘hordes’ and ‘swarms’” of immigrants.”
In the final years of the Obama/Biden Administration,
100,000 illegal aliens claiming to be “refugees” were released
from the southern border into the interior of the USA every MONTH.
A large percentage never showed up for asylum hearings.
Moreover, only a fraction were deemed by courts to be refugees.
Which means the rest were frauds.
Obama/Biden did this with dubious legal justification,
and little support from the American People, who were never consulted.
2 years ago, we saw caravans headed to the border.
Oddly, the caravaners had cell phones and other amenities.
They were not the penniless masses of Eastern and Southern European
immigrants of the turn of the 20th century yearning to breathe free.
The group passed through several countries before they even reached Mexico,
and did not request asylum in any of them.
Was this an asylum emergency or a rush the border scam?
3. “Unlike Joe Biden who has condemned the “anti-Semitic bile” on display at Charlottesville, Virginia, and distanced himself from the anti-Semitism promulgated by figures within his own party”
When did Biden distance himself?
Was that Tamika Mallory at the DNC?
I’d like to know what Biden plans to do with Omar, Tliab,
and a host of other state and local Democrats who have expressed anti-Jewish sentiments.
4. “including the worst one in U.S. history at the Tree of Life Synagogue in Pittsburgh.”
There has been what some have described as a slow motion Pogrom occuring in Brooklyn.
Caught on video in the last few years have been dozens of savage attacks by blacks upon Jews in the Crown Heights, Williamsburg, and Midwood sections.
(All on YouTube).
Problems in these areas date back 50 years.
Funny those were not a concern before, during, or after Pittsburgh.
The victims are poor, bedraggled ultra-orthodox Jews, nobody important.
The perpetrators are exclusively black or Muslim.
All you Jews outraged over “Right Wing anti-Semitism” are invited to spend a semester
on a security patrol on Eastern Parkway and Kings Highway.
You can duke it out with the anti-Semites over there.
5. “Biden is the president who will push the Israelis to make the sacrifices that are conducive to peace”
Jews are about tired of being “pushed”.
And how did Obama’s “pushing” work out?
Let the Israelis decide their own path.
No reason to believe Biden knows better than the duly elected Government of Israel.
6. “Additionally, his views will have a positive impact
in the circles where support for Israel has waned in recent years.”
Any proof?
How did Obama/Biden do in that department?
7. “the election of a liberal president, who strongly backs Israel, will go a long way in shoring up support amongst wavering Democrats — especially on college campuses such as ours.”
See #6
8. “Corruption….White Nationalist…”
Blah blah blah
Cut and paste.
Great article even though I might not agree with 100% of what you said
What I like about the author is he doesn’t even pretend to to be Jewish!
Absolutely brilliant. Well said Joe!